The Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers Association (ICMSA) has warned that any delay to Targeted Agricultural Modernisation Scheme (TAMS) payments in the run-up to Christmas would hit farm families hard, at a time when cashflow is already tight on many holdings.
The farm organisation said its concern centres on the transition between funding streams, which it fears could leave farm families waiting for vital payments during the tight winter cashflow months.
Reliance on payments through December and January
Pat O'Brien, chair of ICMSA's Farm Business Committee, said many farm families would be relying on TAMS payments to help them through December and January, when milk cheques have dried up on many farms across the country. He said he sincerely hoped there would not be a repeat of the delays experienced last year, and that such a situation could not be allowed to happen again.
ICMSA's Christmas warning and its separate criticism of selection rates concern different parts of the same scheme: the speed at which approved payments reach farmers, and the share of applications selected in each tranche.
Dairy selection rate criticised
Separately, O'Brien criticised what he described as an undeniable bias against dairy in the way the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine operates TAMS.
His comments follow confirmation from the Minister for Agriculture, Food and the Marine, Martin Heydon, on Thursday, November 18, that a higher percentage rate will be applied in the ranking and selection process for Tranche 13 of TAMS 3. The minister said selection would be applied on a differentiated basis across the 11 sub-schemes, while applications received under farm safety and nutrient storage schemes would continue to be prioritised.
TAMS 3 is organised around those 11 sub-schemes, and the ranking and selection rate set for a tranche governs what share of applications is chosen under each of them, so a differentiated approach produces different outcomes from one sub-scheme to the next.
O'Brien said that under the rates announced, dairy farmers would face the same selection rate in Tranche 12 as in Tranche 13, which he put at just 20%, while a number of other schemes had benefited from significant increases. He argued that this amounted to a deliberate and consistent policy of withdrawing help and official support from dairy farmers, and said dairy farmers had received that message loud and clear.
O'Brien also singled out the treatment of the Dairy Equipment Scheme, describing its devaluation as particularly revealing. Set against the past 18 months of poor milk prices, he said, it represented the clearest case of hitting a man when he is down, and that this was how ICMSA members had seen it.
