Agriculture

Knackeries halt fallen sheep and horse collections as Fallen Animal Scheme dispute runs into second week

Dario MelnikOctober 27, 20265 min read2 views

At a glance

  • ACA members are also no longer notifying the department of on-farm deaths, while DAFM says it remains open to dialogue and ICMSA warns against any new charges on farmers.
  • Knackery operators affiliated to the Animal Collectors' Association have stopped collecting fallen sheep and horses and are no longer notifying the Department of Agriculture of on-farm deaths, as a dispute over the Fallen Animal Scheme enters a second week. DAFM says it remains open to constructive dialogue, while ICMSA insists any solution must not add to farmer charges.
An empty livestock trailer parked by a farm gate, with sheep standing behind a fence in a rain-dampened field and a plain office building suggested in the distance.

A dispute between knackery operators and the Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine (DAFM) over the Fallen Animal Scheme has entered a second week, with the Animal Collectors' Association (ACA) confirming that its members will stop collecting fallen sheep and horses.

The association said the halt takes effect this week and goes beyond collections: knackeries will also no longer notify the department of animal deaths that occur on farms.

Sampling work has already been affected. Since last Monday, October 19, fallen sheep collected by ACA-affiliated knackery operators have not been prepared and presented to DAFM veterinary staff for sampling for the disease scrapie, according to the association.

Taken together, the steps mark an escalation that followed the expiry of the Fallen Animal Scheme at the end of September, with the ACA withdrawing services it describes as a vital environmental and biosecurity function for Irish agriculture.

Business case submitted ahead of expiry

The ACA said it had submitted what it described as a comprehensive, sustainable business case to the department before the scheme lapsed on September 30. The proposal detailed mechanisms intended to establish a fair and workable scheme for operators, including options aimed at limiting increases in the rates charged to farmers.

The association argued that, instead of engaging constructively with those proposals, the department repeated a long-standing pattern of allowing schemes to run to full expiry before acting, which it said forces knackery operators into an escalating reduction of services.

It said it remains fully committed to providing an environmental and biosecurity service to Irish agriculture, and called on the department to return immediately with a meaningful proposal that protects the infrastructure of the collection system without placing any additional burden on farmers.

Department points to infrastructure role

A department spokesperson said the Fallen Animal Scheme is an important element of Ireland's livestock infrastructure, through which departmental funding supports farmer access to fallen animal collections and protects animal health. The spokesperson said the department is continuing to engage on the matter and remains open and available for constructive dialogue and negotiations.

Farm organisation ICMSA, the Irish Creamery Milk Suppliers' Association, said any solution to the stand-off should not involve higher charges for farmers. Its deputy president, Eamon Carroll, insisted that the answer must come from within the department's own funds.

With the dispute unresolved into a second week, farmers face the loss of collections for fallen sheep and horses, alongside a halt in the preparation of sheep samples for scrapie testing by ACA-affiliated operators.

Reported by Dario Melnik, Harvest and Post-Harvest Systems Editor.